Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


History > Science > Re: Logic in US...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 21 of 33 Topic 358 of 449
Post > Topic >>

Re: Logic in USSR

by Francois Zellinger <k667ap@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jul 24, 2006 at 08:09 PM

On 2006-07-24 Aatu Koskensilta wrote:

> As we all know, it was comrade Stalin's brilliant and objective article 
> _Marxism and linguistics_ in 1951 (IIRC) that established conclusively 
> that language is not a part of the superstructure, and hence formal 
> logic is a legitimate non-ideological discipline. 

Perhaps Stalin made his propaganda and direction job ...

> I'm wondering whether 
> there is any good account of the history of formal logic in USSR, 
> especially in its "ideological aspects" - something like _Science and 
> philosophy in the Soviet Union_ by Loren Graham, but focusing on logic, 
> explicitly excluded by Graham?

.... and let the scientists do their research.

So he was in the fine situation of having control on both. Stalin is
known to be a hard and brutal man, but not as a stupid one.

-- 
Évitez les comparaisons risquées. Ne dites pas: « Dur comme une pine, rond
comme une couille, mouillé comme ma fente, salé comme du foutre, pas plus
gros que mon petit bouton », et autres expressions qui ne sont pas admises
par le dictionnaire de l'Académie. (Pierre Louÿs, Manuel de civilité ...)
 




 33 Posts in Topic:
Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 15:06:10 
Re: Logic in USSR
"jaykov" <ja  2006-07-24 05:37:32 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 15:46:00 
Re: Logic in USSR
"jaykov" <ja  2006-07-24 05:56:37 
Re: Logic in USSR
William Elliot <marsh@  2006-07-24 06:04:51 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 16:13:57 
Re: Logic in USSR
David C. Ullrich <ullr  2006-07-24 08:16:53 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 16:17:04 
Re: Logic in USSR
Frederick Williams <Fr  2006-07-24 13:52:43 
Re: Logic in USSR
Jack Campin - bogus addre  2006-07-24 17:05:56 
Re: Logic in USSR
herbzet@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2006-07-24 17:25:14 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Dan Drake" <  2006-07-24 18:22:40 
Re: Logic in USSR
herbzet@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2006-07-24 19:51:29 
Re: Logic in USSR
David C. Ullrich <ullr  2006-07-25 07:01:20 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Dan Drake" <  2006-07-24 18:18:46 
Re: Logic in USSR
William Elliot <marsh@  2006-07-24 06:05:36 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 16:16:10 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Karl Malbrain"  2006-07-24 09:15:27 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Dan Drake" <  2006-07-24 18:25:19 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-24 21:31:32 
Re: Logic in USSR
Francois Zellinger <k6  2006-07-24 20:09:00 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Dan Drake" <  2006-07-25 19:45:33 
Re: Logic in USSR
William Elliot <marsh@  2006-07-25 00:48:16 
Re: Logic in USSR
Herman Jurjus <h.jurju  2006-07-25 19:53:45 
Re: Logic in USSR
Aatu Koskensilta <aatu  2006-07-25 21:03:05 
Re: Logic in USSR
"George Dance"   2006-07-29 04:08:38 
Re: Logic in USSR
"George Dance"   2006-07-29 05:47:25 
Re: Logic in USSR
"George Dance"   2006-07-29 08:41:24 
Re: Logic in USSR
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2006-07-29 21:45:13 
Re: Logic in USSR
"Dan Drake" <  2006-07-31 20:18:33 
Re: Logic in USSR
Nam Nguyen <namducnguy  2006-07-31 21:55:30 
Re: Logic in USSR
"George Dance"   2006-07-31 03:24:38 
Re: Logic in USSR
"George Dance"   2006-07-31 14:30:33 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Nov 22 1:22:10 CST 2008.