Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


History > Science > Re: Linguistic ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 19 of 19 Topic 419 of 449
Post > Topic >>

Re: Linguistic roots Re: branches of science

by Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Nov 29, 2007 at 03:44 PM

On Nov 28, 9:51 am, b...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 (Robert Grumbine) wrote:
>
>
>   It doesn't provide _roots_, it provides a description of ties of
> linguistic influence in the British isles (not English, notwithstanding
> its assertion.)   (Also misses divergence of Celtic into its two main
> branches and then subdivision, and omits Cornish entirely).
> 'Renaissance' is not a language I've ever heard of.  Perhaps you can
> explain that one?  It's also a pretty egregious lumping to put
> Spanish and 'American Indian' as a single group influence.
>
Yes, I looked it over more carefully, and noticed the problems you
mention.

>   For both the language thing and for science, I consider it im****tant
> that the picture be meaningful.  It's insufficient to merely list
> a bunch of things in a pleasant graphic

Yes, again. I want to avoid this. I'm now getting ready to study that
material on graphs that John mentioned. I had no idea that there was a
theory of graphs. This looks pretty interesting. I'll be in touch.



>
> --
> Robert Grumbinehttp://www.radix.net/~bobg/Science
faqs and amateur
activities notes and links.
> Sagredo (Galileo Galilei) "You present these recondite matters with too
much
> evidence and ease; this great facility makes them less appreciated than
they
> would be had they been presented in a more abstruse manner." Two New
Sciences
 




 19 Posts in Topic:
branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-25 11:49:18 
Re: branches of science
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2007-11-26 08:37:52 
Re: branches of science
bobg@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2007-11-26 00:39:47 
Re: branches of science
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2007-11-26 11:42:10 
Re: branches of science
bobg@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2007-11-27 16:36:03 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-25 19:37:39 
Re: branches of science
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2007-11-26 14:14:40 
Linguistic roots Re: branches of science
bobg@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2007-11-27 17:04:40 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-25 19:40:54 
Re: branches of science
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2007-11-26 14:14:40 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-25 19:51:44 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-26 16:08:56 
Re: Linguistic roots Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-27 17:01:46 
Re: Linguistic roots Re: branches of science
bobg@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2007-11-28 14:51:44 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-27 17:04:06 
Re: branches of science
j.wilkins1@[EMAIL PROTECT  2007-11-28 11:13:46 
Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-28 16:03:03 
Re: Linguistic roots Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-28 16:04:26 
Re: Linguistic roots Re: branches of science
Martin <mgcqso@[EMAIL   2007-11-29 15:44:39 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sat Nov 22 5:38:36 CST 2008.