Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


History > History What if > Re: Future of Y...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 13 of 40 Topic 15316 of 15951
Post > Topic >>

Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world

by randy.mcdonald@[EMAIL PROTECTED] Jul 9, 2008 at 11:44 PM

On Jul 8, 11:56=A0pm, bm2...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
>
> [deletia]
>
> Under this sort of scenario, what odds that a high percentage of the
> Yiddish-speaking Jews of eastern Europe still are doing so in 2008?
> Given nationalist pressures to assimilate, and efforts to make them
> proper Soviets in the USSR, possibly at gulag-point, one would think
> there would be a serious drop in the number of Yiddish-speakers: and
> not only by assimilation, but also by emigration (in a WWII-free
> world, how long does the US keep its immigration as restricted as it
> was during the 30's?).

I'd separate the Soviet Jews from the non-Soviet central and eastern
European Jews. Soviet Jews, as has been noted elsewhere in this
thread, were assimilating strongly to Russian culture even before the
Revolution.

Yiddish-speaking Jews in non-Soviet Europe would be different, with
their relatively and absolutely larger numbers and the existence of
strong barriers to assimilation via prejudice and residential
segregation and whatnot. There likely would be a non-trivial amount of
language ****ft, but would there be that much?

All the best,
Randy
 




 40 Posts in Topic:
Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
bm2617@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-08 20:56:19 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Dan Goodman" &  2008-07-09 05:46:53 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Robert Savage <rbsavag  2008-07-09 14:59:37 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
akup@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2008-07-09 13:48:14 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Old Toby <tobiasburmei  2008-07-11 14:22:13 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
bm2617@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-09 07:25:34 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-09 08:23:00 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
akup@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2008-07-09 16:40:14 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-09 10:21:04 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
akup@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2008-07-10 21:30:18 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Rich Rostrom <rrostrom  2008-07-10 21:40:58 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Rich Rostrom <rrostrom  2008-07-09 15:42:10 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
randy.mcdonald@[EMAIL PRO  2008-07-09 23:44:37 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-10 09:35:11 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Mark Edelstein <edelst  2008-07-10 03:22:12 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Lee Ratner <LBRatner@[  2008-07-10 12:07:22 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Old Toby <tobiasburmei  2008-07-11 13:29:40 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-10 14:21:56 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-11 09:14:57 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-10 19:16:20 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-11 05:03:27 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-11 15:14:57 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-11 06:54:02 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-11 16:24:46 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
Old Toby <tobiasburmei  2008-07-11 14:29:31 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-11 09:01:35 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-14 10:46:32 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-11 11:51:17 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-14 05:41:10 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
jussi.jalonen@[EMAIL PROT  2008-07-14 06:24:05 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-14 17:12:27 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
The Horny Goat <lcrave  2008-07-15 01:44:06 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-15 09:56:02 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
The Horny Goat <lcrave  2008-07-17 05:46:27 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
The Horny Goat <lcrave  2008-07-15 01:29:02 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
bm2617@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-14 08:00:30 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-14 11:21:37 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
"Michele" <n  2008-07-15 09:46:37 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
jussi.jalonen@[EMAIL PROT  2008-07-15 04:58:13 
Re: Future of Yiddish Eastern Europe in no-WWII world
am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-07-15 05:40:29 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sun Nov 23 11:18:19 CST 2008.