<am05@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> ha scritto nel messaggio
news:61f49976-4f18-48ab-b22f-5649252c36f1@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Jul 14, 11:12 am, "Michele" <nospammiar...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> <jussi.jalo...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> ha scritto nel
>
messaggionews:10acf913-f527-4f5d-b44d-de3799b6da8b@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> On 11 heinä, 17:24, "Michele" <nospammiar...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
> - By way of further comparison, note how a political philosophy,
> Communism,
> was already existing and robust both in theory and practical
applications
> before Stalin came to power.
>Some considerations with which you may or may not agree:
>1. What exactly 'came tro power' stands for?
The time when he was in a comparable position to Hitler.
>2. 'Communism' as a theory created by Marx had nothing to do with the
Bolshevik Revolution and actually was in a serious contradiction with
the realities of this event.
Of course. That's why I said that as _a political philosophy_ it already
existed, _both in theory and in practical applications_. Evidently, if
they
were all one and the same, I would not have made those distinctions.
> Stalin was not another Party apparatchik, and
> the end result is that many historians prefer to coin and use a
name-based
> trademark, Stalinism, not to be mixed up with Communism.
>Taking into an account that nobody can tell for sure what 'Communism'
is suppossed to stay for, this statement may or may not be true,
depending on person's opinion.
In fact, I did not espouse it myself. I only pointed out that many
historians go for it.
>Nazism, much less, before and after Hitler.
>This can be explained by the fact that Nazism was thoroughly defeated
with its active followers being chaced down and taken care of.
However, there _are_ neo-Nazies even now.
Indeed, I did not state that Nazism disappeared with the end of Hitler. I
stated that after the end of Hitler it had much less life than Communism
after the end of Stalin, and I stand by that statement. The neo-Nazis are
a
few fringe lunatics, while neo-Communists are in power in several
countries.
|
