Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


History > History What if > Re: Abolition i...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 4 of 59 Topic 15591 of 15951
Post > Topic >>

Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians

by The Horny Goat <lcraver@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Aug 28, 2008 at 04:43 AM

On Wed, 27 Aug 2008 20:53:17 -0500, raystwo@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 (Raymond Speer)
wrote:

>And when they talk about the American Civil War, the neo-Confederates
>don't have the honesty to admit the South fought to keep Blacks in
>chains for eternity.  The War was  over manufacturing over agriculture;
>limited government against  too-powerful governments; people with good
>personalities and the bad people in the other section; constitutional
>rules of interpretation or whatever.  If the War was all about some
>cramped, mean, trivial point --- well, maybe the winners won for nothing
>beyond their own bigger battalions. 
>
>The Civil War was about slavery just as the strength behind John McCain
>is that his complexion is white. 

In fairness I'm not an American and >I< can tell (having last night
sat for Hillary and the previous 3 speakers before her) that there's a
lot more to this election than race - sure it's a factor for some
folks, but it's hardly the whole story.

The way you've just put it anyone who votes Republican is a racist
which is far from fair.
 




 59 Posts in Topic:
Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Morning   2008-08-27 19:21:41 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-27 17:01:28 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
raystwo@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-08-27 20:53:17 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
The Horny Goat <lcrave  2008-08-28 04:43:19 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-29 15:44:47 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"the Bede" <  2008-08-27 21:18:34 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
heekster <heekster@[EM  2008-08-30 08:39:37 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-30 11:56:26 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"the Bede" <  2008-08-30 11:04:21 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
heekster <heekster@[EM  2008-08-31 16:29:38 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-30 12:16:33 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
heekster <heekster@[EM  2008-08-31 16:24:36 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-09-01 01:54:45 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
heekster <heekster@[EM  2008-09-01 13:12:36 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-27 20:11:31 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-28 08:45:38 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"William Black"  2008-08-28 16:52:15 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
David Johnston <david@  2008-08-29 16:36:55 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-29 15:46:43 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-28 10:09:00 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-29 21:30:44 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-30 12:20:14 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-30 21:14:13 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-31 03:26:13 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-28 10:32:22 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-29 15:48:24 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-29 21:40:36 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-28 10:56:37 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
SilentOtto <silentotto  2008-08-28 13:43:03 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
akup@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2008-08-29 13:51:35 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Mike stone" &l  2008-08-29 16:45:48 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-29 15:50:19 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
HankC <clarkc@[EMAIL P  2008-08-29 11:05:49 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-29 14:29:08 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-29 20:31:45 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-29 22:04:00 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-29 20:38:50 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
S Witmer <witmergreen@  2008-08-29 20:53:32 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
cigarmanwine@[EMAIL PROTE  2008-08-29 23:21:35 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
SilentOtto <silentotto  2008-08-30 00:24:26 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-30 09:23:34 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-30 21:22:19 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-30 09:28:34 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-30 17:27:39 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Barry" <bar  2008-08-30 21:20:42 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-31 03:27:32 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
raystwo@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-08-31 09:44:20 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
nada <dwaltersMIA@[EMA  2008-08-30 21:28:22 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-31 03:35:34 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
nada <dwaltersMIA@[EMA  2008-08-31 09:37:21 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-31 12:56:25 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"the Bede" <  2008-08-31 12:35:54 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
Lazarusburningin Hell <  2008-08-31 13:48:18 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
Ol Whicker Bill <ol@[E  2008-08-31 14:14:32 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-31 16:45:11 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-31 16:44:51 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"Raymond O'Hara"  2008-08-31 16:41:28 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"F~A~R~V~A: Suave Co  2008-08-31 16:45:59 
Re: Abolition is overemphasized by modern historians
"deemsbill@[EMAIL PR  2008-08-31 16:19:01 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Sun Nov 23 9:31:07 CST 2008.