Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


History > History What if > Re: What IF: Ja...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 63 of 80 Topic 15562 of 16017
Post > Topic >>

Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?

by dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Aug 28, 2008 at 12:12 PM

On Aug 28, 2:50=A0pm, Stephen Graham wrote:

> >> Oh, well in that case, subtract 50% of them due to prompt defections
> >> back to the United States.
>
> > The flip side of that one being, how many of the US tankfarm sentries
> > were of Japanese ethnic background on Dec.7'41 ?
>
> Based on your research, which units were the sentries drawn from?

Thanks for the invitation but I have no desire at all to get drawn
into that particular racism debate.

> I'll point out that there is no record of any nisei members of the US
> Army not doing their duty, as well as no record of any sabotage on the
> part of the Japanese American population.

I couldn't agree more but must point out that the US authorities acted
swiftly to "round up" and detain some 1,500 of the "usual Japanese
suspects" in the two days after the PH attacks, under the martial law
regulations proclaimed. Perhaps they just got lucky and picked up all
the potential sabateurs, before they could do any harm ?

I'll also point out that there is no record of Japanese paratroopers
"on the ground" on Oahu either. Perhaps some nisei or issei members of
the Hawaiian community might have been more inspired to come to the
aid of their Japanese homeland after they believed that the Japanese
had indeed landed ? I suspect not but we'll never know for sure, now.
 




 80 Posts in Topic:
What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-23 22:07:03 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
raystwo@[EMAIL PROTECTED]  2008-08-24 10:45:28 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Anthony Buckland&qu  2008-08-24 14:27:55 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-24 09:48:08 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
J.J. O'Shea <try.not.t  2008-08-24 18:32:39 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-25 11:00:45 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
J.J. O'Shea <try.not.t  2008-08-25 07:16:47 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
tmcd@[EMAIL PROTECTED] (  2008-09-13 23:43:48 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-24 17:16:36 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-25 11:10:00 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
David H Thornley <davi  2008-08-24 23:04:22 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
SolomonW <SolomonW@[EM  2008-08-27 00:44:17 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-24 21:59:19 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-25 06:18:52 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-25 17:53:18 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Jenny Brien" &  2008-08-25 17:36:04 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
kenney@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-08-26 04:37:22 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-26 15:28:59 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-26 09:14:53 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
kenney@[EMAIL PROTECTED]   2008-08-27 17:19:32 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-27 19:53:30 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-25 06:30:35 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-25 16:42:38 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
The Old Man <Braungart  2008-08-25 06:59:21 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-26 11:16:52 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-25 09:23:39 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-25 18:32:00 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-25 11:29:51 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-25 15:51:53 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-26 10:34:21 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-25 16:04:52 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
The Old Man <Braungart  2008-08-26 04:57:31 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-08-26 15:24:53 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"news.iglou.com"  2008-08-26 17:20:59 
The Soviet Training City
"news.iglou.com"  2008-08-26 17:27:48 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"William Black"  2008-08-26 22:56:46 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"a425couple" &l  2008-08-28 08:28:12 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"news.iglou.com"  2008-08-28 18:08:52 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"a425couple" &l  2008-08-29 08:33:46 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-26 07:19:40 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-26 08:31:27 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Dennis <tsalagi18NOSPA  2008-09-09 06:22:59 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"a425couple" &l  2008-08-26 09:23:25 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-26 09:56:38 
Re: What IF: Japan-Para to PH - staff planning
"a425couple" &l  2008-08-28 09:59:13 
Re: The Soviet Training City
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-26 15:42:05 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"Anthony Buckland&qu  2008-08-26 17:34:53 
Re: The Soviet Training City
Dennis <tsalagi18NOSPA  2008-09-09 06:25:29 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"William Black"  2008-09-09 15:44:33 
Re: The Soviet Training City
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-27 11:06:00 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"William Black"  2008-08-27 22:40:25 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Stephen Graham <graham  2008-08-27 16:41:51 
Re: The Soviet Training City
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-27 19:50:10 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"William Black"  2008-08-28 14:22:55 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-27 19:56:52 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Dimensional Travele  2008-08-27 23:35:17 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Stephen Graham <graham  2008-08-28 11:50:30 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-28 03:57:25 
Re: The Soviet Training City
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-28 06:33:20 
Re: The Soviet Training City
Invid Fan <invid@[EMAI  2008-08-29 14:01:02 
Re: What IF: Japan-Para to PH - staff planning
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-28 11:54:36 
Re: What IF: Japan-Para to PH - staff planning
"a425couple" &l  2008-08-28 13:44:54 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-28 12:12:35 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Stephen Graham <graham  2008-08-28 13:58:20 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-29 04:16:02 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Stephen Graham <graham  2008-08-29 13:43:33 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
The Old Man <Braungart  2008-08-29 04:17:07 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Stephen Graham <graham  2008-08-29 13:46:03 
Re: The Soviet Training City
The Old Man <Braungart  2008-08-29 04:28:33 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-29 04:38:15 
Re: The Soviet Training City
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-08-29 10:20:56 
Re: The Soviet Training City
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-29 13:36:24 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
dabrob <dabrob@[EMAIL   2008-08-29 17:29:43 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-09-09 03:03:22 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Dennis <tsalagi18NOSPA  2008-09-09 20:49:52 
Re: The Soviet Training City
"Paul J. Adam"   2008-09-09 17:23:43 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Jack Linthicum <jackli  2008-09-09 14:10:47 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Dennis <tsalagi18NOSPA  2008-09-11 02:06:49 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
"Michele" <n  2008-09-11 16:09:22 
Re: What IF: Japan Sent Paratroops to Pearl Harbor ?
Dennis <tsalagi18NOSPA  2008-09-11 22:19:14 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Tue Dec 2 5:45:26 CST 2008.